Clapping In Church

I remember when clapping in church was frowned upon. Even after I became a pastor, the debate continued to produce angst. I was on the side of clapping “when appropriate.” My stance opened Pandora’s box on several occasions. Yet, I remain steadfast in my straddling the fence between always clapping and never clapping. Allow me to define my “when appropriate” stance.

I clap when the anthem or special music is inspiring and upbeat. I do not clap for the performers who are offering their gifts to God. They are not primarily there for our entertainment. Instead, I am clapping to participate in the celebration of the moment. My only caveat is children. I clap for children so that each one knows they are appreciated for the gifts they share and their bravery and to show a sense of affirming love. I trust that adult performers do not need my affirmation in the worship context. When we applaud the performer, it has the unintended consequence of transforming the worship experience into an act of performing, which is not the goal of the service. Clapping can actually diminish the performer by taking their sacred offering and turning it into something focused on them rather than on God.

The more difficult challenge is recognizing when not to clap. The congregation in attendance must rely on intuition and feelings. When a piece of music is intended to make one reflect at a deeper level, beyond celebration, the congregation should refrain from applause. Often, the director selects a piece of music that resonates with the Scriptures and the sermon. Meditative music is intended to leave the music sitting in the air, with the silence being the final phrase of the musical score. Applause interrupts the contemplative silence, breaking the prayerful tone and even interrupting the composer and choir’s final silent notes.

In this confusing age of worship, it is challenging for a group of hundreds to reach a communal agreement. Yet, when a congregation agrees on a response, you feel its power. The hairs on the back of my neck stand up when a joyous piece concludes, and the congregation, in unison, is moved to stand and applaud joyously. It is just as inspiring when a meditative piece concludes, and you feel the corporate hush in the sanctuary. Silence can sometimes be louder than pounding applause.

Please read the meaning behind the piece of music each week. Feel what the person or choir is trying to convey. When raucous, it is good to respond with celebratory applause. When the music features minor keys and has a meditative feel, refrain from clapping so that the silent final notes fill the sanctuary, allowing the music to weave its way into our hearts. The performers’ goal is not applause but to have us experience the meaning of their musical offering. Respect their gift by responding appropriately.

Thank you for your reflection on this significant issue.

Pastor Scott